Plan Ahead — How To Choose A Roofing Solution

When a roof problem shows up on your watch, you need options — and clarity. This guide breaks down the practical paths leaders consider: repair, restore (coat), overlay/layover, metal retrofit, or full replacement. It also flags what to ask before you decide and how to plan budgets without surprises.

First: Know Your Starting Point

Before choosing a path, verify roof age, recent leak history, membrane type (TPO, EPDM, BUR/modified, metal), insulation condition, and deck integrity. A disciplined inspection that documents seams, penetrations, terminations, and drainage finds issues an untrained eye can miss. That kind of documentation speeds decisions and helps you prioritize work.

Your Option Set (When Each Makes Sense)

1) Targeted Repair
Best for isolated defects (open lap, failed flashing, puncture) on otherwise sound systems. Repairs stop active leaks and protect insulation from saturating — which preserves energy performance and avoids tear-outs later. Pair repairs with routine checks to keep small problems small.

2) Restore with a Coating
Fluid-applied roof coatings can extend life and improve weathering when the underlying membrane and insulation are dry and stable. Typical life spans range about 15–25 years, depending on product, film thickness, and maintenance.

3) Overlay/Layover (Recover)
Adding a new membrane over an old one (where code and manufacturer allow) reduces tear-off cost and disruption. Good for systems with limited wet areas and a deck in good condition. Use testing to locate and remove any saturated insulation first. For a quick compare of replacement vs. layover considerations, see CRC’s guide.

4) Metal Retrofit
If you have aging metal with recurring leaks at fasteners and laps, a retrofit assembly (new membrane and insulation over the metal) can improve weather performance and thermal value without a full structural replacement. (CRC offers guidance on retrofit strategy alongside other roof system options.)

5) Full Replacement
Required when moisture is widespread, the deck is compromised, or the system is at end of life. Replacement also lets you upgrade to systems with manufacturer warranties — for example, single-ply assemblies installed by certified crews are often inspected and warranted by the manufacturer.

A Quick Primer on Common Systems

• TPO (thermoplastic) — Light, weldable seams, common on low-slope. Requires trained, manufacturer-aligned installation; many systems are eligible for long manufacturer warranties.
• EPDM (rubber) — Proven longevity and flexibility; details at penetrations and edges need disciplined execution and maintenance. (See CRC’s roofing system resources for comparisons.)
• Built-Up/Modified Bitumen — Multi-ply durability; pay close attention to flashings and drains during inspections. (CRC blogs and system pages cover pros and cons by system.)

Budget Planning: How Leaders Control Cost Without Cutting Corners

• Compare materials, labor, and scope carefully. Price varies by size, condition, and complexity; choose for longevity and energy performance, not sticker price alone.
• Prioritize work. Tackle critical risks now, schedule medium-priority items, and group low-priority tasks strategically.
• Lean on maintenance. Routine inspections and small repairs prevent major issues — and keep total cost lower over time.
• Time your project. Off-season scheduling can ease labor pressure and reduce queue delays.

Why Contractor Qualifications Matter

Kentucky and Indiana do not license roofing contractors — which means anyone with a truck can claim to be one. KRCA’s Certified Contractor program gives you an objective bar for insurance, bonding, ethics, and ongoing education. Choosing KRCA-certified professionals helps you avoid avoidable risk.

Safety, Service, & Quality — every day since 1981.
Louisville: (502) 459-2216
Hebron: (859) 943-0012
Service: (888) 818-4842
commonwealthroofing.com